I am coding with Claude these days. Claude doing the editing. There is no way for that to happen. Tells me Elon is talking out his neather region.
1 Like
You have listed few thingsā¦ does he own any patents on the below? Like I said he identified critical problems, then brought together teams. He didnāt invent anything specifc.
6 Likes
Musk doesnāt tend patent very much. Heās been generous in that way. I donāt define innovator in as limited of a way as you do. Sometimes, itās the person that has the vision and builds the team and business that executes it. Sometimes, itās just improving on a process or product.
Iām guessing if we surveyed a 100 people and asked them to name their top 5 innovators, Musk is probably a name mentioned a majority of the time.
1 Like
The word innovator has a definition. Of course I call my kid as āinnovativeā when he tries to scam me some money for his pizza, but that doesnāt make him an innovator.
2 Likes
Because he didnāt invent anything, at least āfirst inventionsāā¦ all those technologies, rockets, lithium-ion batteries, EV, and neural interface all predates him.
He is exceptionally good, in finding exceptional talent, systems integration, capital raise, and allocation, and to some degree bringing cost down and delivering results. On delivering results many have different views but Colossus is an example of him delivering on accelerated pace.
I will give all of the above. But he also has fair share of failures.
5 Likes
In a business context, we would call that fraud. When my child does it, I call it creative manipulation. What can I say, the G20 held a 2 day Innovation ministerial. They chose to have Musk, among other āinnovatorsā, speak. I am assuming itās for some pertinent reason related to the topic of innovation.
Itās okay recognize his contributions whether you like him personally or detest him. We can separate a personās accomplishments from the other aspects, with which one might rightly disagree. Steve Jobs was in many ways not a great human being. I can still appreciate his achievements.
Almost all the great innovators and pioneers had a long list of failures that preceded their eventual success. Itās not a flaw but evidence of persistence.
The difference is they were real innovators, and their path to innovation is to failā¦ you keep trying until you succeed. Musk is basically a business guy with an engineering background. My quibble is not with him but calling him as innovator.
1 Like
Iām looking at it and it goes round and round. Itās like a circle. The over $2 trillion backlog of hyperscalers is artificially pumped up by self dealing. $200 billion+ contracts are being passed around like a blunt and RPOs are flying higher than a kite.
2 Likes
First off, Musk doesnāt have a background in engineering, which makes it all that much more remarkable. He has a BA in Economics and Physics.
MUSKās Role in the early development of SPACE X.
- Technical Oversight: Rather than acting solely as an investor or manager, Musk serves as chief engineer, deeply involving himself in hardware, vehicle architecture, and design decisions. [1, 2]
- Hands-on Problem Solving: He worked alongside early engineering hiresāsuch as propulsion lead Tom Muellerāto develop the Merlin engine and structure the Falcon 1, Falcon 9, and Starship programs. [1, 2]
Forbes Ranking: In February 2026, Forbes ranked Elon Musk No. 1 on its inaugural list of Americaās 250 Greatest Innovators.
Not true. The RPO is real, not self dealing but unlike the past cloudera RPO, these are at significant risk, because bulk of the RPO are from OpenAI and Anthropic.
Itās sooo very true.
"At its simplest, circular financing describes a deal structure in which a chipmaker or hyperscaler takes an equity stake in, or extends credit to, an AI lab or neocloud provider, and that same company then commits to multi-year purchases of chips or computing power from the firm that just funded it. The money moves in a loop: invest, then buy back, then invest again.
Circular financing is not illegal, and it is not new. Wall Street has seen versions of this for decades, including vendor financing during the telecom boom in the late 1990s, when equipment makers lent money to buyers so those buyers could afford to buy more equipment. What is new, however, is the unprecedented scale of these deals in the AI sector."
4 Likes
OK believe what you wantā¦ Here is one data point, Amazon, specifically AWS has participated in 3 round of anthropic funding, for a total of $13 B. Anthropic has 10 year $100 B commitment to use AWS data center and amazon chips.
There are folks who scream that is circular investment, OTOH, someone like me may view that as tech companies investing in a hot technology startup and of course establishing relationship with those companies who will become their big customers.
For context AWS RPO sits at $496 B. There are various risk associated with the RPOās and whether Anthropic, OpenAI can execute on those contracts needs to be seen, but just dismissing it all as circular financing is lazy.
To clarify - Iām not suggesting the deals arenāt real, or the RPOs are fake. Iām suggesting that the circular nature of the deals artificially pumps up enterprise demand. Future revenues for the hyperscalers are being counted once, twice, three times maaaybe. Also, hyperscalersā RPOs are tied so tightly together, that any shock to the system will ripple through it in potentially devasting ways. Also, also, as you mentioned, 50% of the hyperscalersā RPOs are coming from 2 unprofitable companies.
4 Likes
A perfectly articulated statement about the essence of the real task of high end āprogrammingāā¦.and management, and what was anciently and still is called ācraftmanshipā.
5 Likes
A mechanical engineering program is physics.
Not an innovator but yet. . .
Forbes Ranking: In February 2026, Forbes ranked Elon Musk No. 1 on its inaugural list of Americaās 250 Greatest Innovators.
Forbes thought Trumpās networth was high when he lied about it to them.
1 Like
are you landing 20 story buildings?
I am not impressed by someone who goes bankrupt.
I am impressed by someone who goes bankrupt four times.