How Venezuela managed Exxon

By the time Venezuela collapsed, all the oil companies had been nationalized and PDVSA was doing a fair job pumping oil. Chavez fired PDVSA’s management who were mostly oil company alumni who really knew their job.

Before the oil companies were nationalized Venezuela had learned how to avoid the oil companies’ scam and skim. They were allowed to sell oil at any price they wished! They were taxed based on a government set price. :slightly_smiling_face:

What destroyed the economy was the mismanagement of the national investment fund.

The Captain

3 Likes

There were a number of factors. Norway maintained a strong relationship with private corporate partners with expertise in the oil and gas industry. As you point out, Norway socked away the funds to provide for future pension benefits and also manage the volatility that would inevitably occur in spending and oil revenue.

Venezuela turned around and spent every dollar and then some on public give backs, along with large losses due to corruption and political favoritism. Most importantly, Chavez basically dismantled the checks and balances that existed to protect against fraud and corruption. Norway has a long history strong and impartial institutions which prevents the kind of centralized power that weakens other institutions. Norway’s transition was also a more orderly affair. Chavez was elected on the heels of what had already been a severe economic crisis and an existing culture plagued by corruption.

1 Like

Just as a follow on, there are still two primary risks with these state run/owned assets.

  1. How it played out in Venezuela where there is mismanagement and no fiscal discipline.

  2. Norway’s tax revenues are highly dependent on oil and gas (35%). With that type of monopoly, there is a potential risk that as the dependency on fossil fuels changes, does the economy shift the way it would with private sector growth and capital getting deployed elsewhere, as industries die off or become obsolete?

Sure. And there are lots of examples of privately owned companies which are badly managed and which go toes up.

There are also lots of state owned industries that do just fine, thank you. I live in the area of TVA, which manages rivers and dams, solar farms and hydroelectric production, nuclear plants and oil fired plants which touch or envelop seven states. They have significant grid to maintain over tens of thousands of square miles, and We have among the lowest electrical costs in the country.

Singapore Airlines is nearly always rated near the top of global airlines, it is entirely run by the Singapore Government.

Saudi Aramco has been a state owned industry for decades, recently allowing private investors in, but it has been efficiently run since it was formed in the mid 20th century.

China’s State Grid corporation is run a heck of a lot better than PG&E, that’s for sure.

There are dozens of such examples, and obviously examples of those which are poorly run. I want to say “The Manhattan Project”, although that one no longer exists, but it did something that private industry never would have or could have.

3 Likes

It doesn’t address the issue that I raised. Public co-opting of private businesses where the govt does not have a strong checks and balances or where corruption exists can be a disaster. Second, the private markets have a strong incentive to grow and innovate to avoid extinction. Govt’s and their leaders don’t have that moral hazard. So, the question becomes what happens if those industries die off and with them a key source of public revenues?

It’s not an endorsement of only private run businesses or that all public run operations are bad thing. It’s an acknowledgment of a couple of risks of the latter. Why are these conversations always treated as if the position has to be binary?

There is also an economic phenomenon called Dutch Disease which was described after the Netherlands discovered extensive natural gas resources. When a windfall resource like oil or natural gas is developed, the resulting exports result in large imports of foreign currency, which causes the domestic currency to appreciate. This in turn causes imports to be artificially cheap and exports expensive which causes a hollowing out of domestic industries. This is mostly okay as long as the price of oil is high, but when the price of oil drops there is no fall back position. We saw the result of this in 2014-16 in Venezuela, with a price drop in oil resulting in widespread political unrest. Other countries experienced negative effects of Dutch Disease at this time as well.

Norway has mostly avoided Dutch Disease by investing their Sovereign Wealth Fund entirely outside of the country and greatly restricting the amount of spending from oil revenues. Very responsible and far sighted thinking.

7 Likes

Venezuela used to be a prime exporter of coffee and cacao. The Caracas valley was a coffee plantation. When my grandfather was alive you could still find coffee shrubs in Parque Los Caobos, “Mahogany Park.” Once oil was discovered agriculture died as oil companies paid better wages.

GoogleAI:

Historical Context of Coffee in the Caracas Valley

  • Colonial Beginnings: Coffee cultivation in the Caracas Valley began around 1783–1784 on estates like La Floresta and Blandín (now areas like La Castellana and the Caracas Country Club). [1, 2]
  • Shade-Grown Tradition: Coffee plants in Venezuela were traditionally grown under the canopy of large native trees, such as mahogany, which provided essential shade and protected the soil. [1, 2]
  • Economic Shift: By the early 20th century, Venezuela was one of the world’s top coffee exporters, before the national economy heavily pivoted toward petroleum following oil discoveries in the 1910s and 1920s. [1, 2, 3]
  • The Park’s Evolution: Formerly an agricultural property, the space was designated as a public park (initially as Parque Sucre) and renamed Los Caobos in 1937 to honor its dense stand of mature mahogany trees. [1]

The Captain

2 Likes