Thanks Bulwinkle - Although I’ve picked a few stocks starting when I was twelve, and usually done quite well - I started doing it with actual amounts of money that actually matter for about a year. (So, “not long” as compared with Saul, say!)
I’ve had maybe 40% in a mutual fund, something like you suggest, and the rest in stocks.
But the devil is in the details.
Fidelity says I’m up 23% for the past year, including the 10% gain in the mutual fund - which would seem to mean I’ve done well with the stocks I’ve picked. BUT this doesn’t count the money I took out of Fidelity (embarrassed to say, around 25%), and stupidly was trading with a computer. No, I didn’t lose it all, only about 10% - but of course I lost the upside potential had I left that capital in something approaching sensible investing, in a bull market.
Another thing that would have given me a greater return is that sometime early this year I got worried about all my things like Nividia, and even Amazon - was there some bad week or day in February? - and mostly because I didn’t know what the hell I was doing, I sold a lot of the FANG/tech stuff and put more into the mutual fund at that point, so…
Anyway, my entire investing universe is up far less than 23%! It’s comforting Fidelity says that, but a) that’s through Septmember, so doesn’t include my October surprise (see below) and b) it doesn’t count the opportunity cost of that 25%, nor the c) 2.5% I lost being stupid (ie “trading”). (Being literally foolish, as opposed to “foolish”.)
“Live in learn” is nice, but I’d rather learn first. You guys do the living, I’ll do the learning - how’s that?
(Oh, btw, my initial “investment” in Nvda was in, like, 2015? But it was just one share! haha. And I got two other things DG advised, I think Baby and something else, so it was mostly a wash, though NVDA was up, like…1450% or something? Something crazy. Almost enough for a pizza!)
FOMA:
The other STUPID STUPID STUPID STUPID thing I did only a week or two ago was, after discovering Saul, I went on a selling and buying spree, and ended up with, like, 8% in AYG, same in ZS, in one day - one morning - like the day, or the day before, everything sank. And I freaked out, as maybe others have done at least once in their lives, and sold most of those purchases at a loss (keeping v small amounts), realising I should have recognised that Saul’s “starter position” is the functional equivalent of “cost averaging”, even if he thinks about it differently.
(FOMA)
I suppose it’s not hugely tragic in your eyes, but it hurt like hell to see everything drop.
I decided to punish myself, (well, no choice, really,) and not buy something I really wanted to get (a car that’s not a death trap - although, come to think of it, maybe THAT would be, in its own way, a wise investment! That was my rationalization, but as the amount I lost was more than the cost of the - used - car I wanted…well…too many details, except not:
I see I made another mistake, conflating short term (what will I buy in the next few months) with long term (investing…)
So that’s my story…for now
Nice name though, huh? I never intended it to be publicly used…but after discovering this board, well….not a bad name, is it?
Thanks again everyone who responded! Remember, this is my new motto. You live, I learn! (I’ve made enough mistakes for the year…)
Croesus