OT: Cognitive dissonance for a Sunday morning

Appropro of nothing, I offer the first few paragraphs from a story in today’s Wall Street Journal. This is a strange, but compelling narrative:

YAEDA VALLEY, Tanzania—In a bygone era, 27-year-old Emmanuel Mussa would likely have been preparing arrows tipped with the poison from the desert rose for a hunt across the forested plains with other Hadzabe tribesmen.

But on a recent morning, the university graduate was dusting the crimson fuel tank of his Chinese-made motorbike before beginning a 5-mile ride to his office in a nearby settlement, where he works as a project manager for a social enterprise selling carbon credits.

Mussa also regularly visits the town of Mbulu, 30 miles away, to buy groceries. He lives in an iron-roofed house, tends a small potato garden in his front yard and tracks global events—from the conflicts in the Middle East to European soccer—via his smartphone.

It is a stark illustration of how one of the world’s last hunter-gatherer societies is being absorbed into the modern world.

Anthropologists believe the Hadzabe—who number fewer than 1,300 people—have roamed the Yaeda Valley in northern Tanzania for more than 50,000 years. They are believed to be the second-oldest people on Earth after the San people of southern Africa. Living in nomadic groups, the men use handmade bows and arrows to hunt Cape buffalo, baboons and the rodent-like hyrax. They climb giant baobab trees to raid beehives for honey. Women forage for fruit and tubers.

For generations, the Hadzabe, [also known as the Hadza], have kept their distance from modern agriculture, guns, missionaries, poachers and encroaching pastoralists. They are the only ethnic group in Tanzania allowed to hunt and gather food in protected areas,

More

https://www.wsj.com/world/africa/the-hunter-gatherers-weighing-whether-to-join-the-modern-world-0cc1bf6f

8 Likes

How many Inuit (Eskimos) do you see living in igloos and hunting seals with dog sleds and walrus ivory tipped spears?

There’s a reason the Inuit live in heated homes, drive snowmobiles and hunt with rifles. The hunter-gatherer lifestyle is difficult and requires constant daily effort compared with the modern lifestyle.

I read the same article and wondered whether it’s fair to isolate traditional tribes and force them to stay primitive. The Hazda seem to have choices. They are given a protected area for hunting and gathering but also enough financial resources to buy modern education and medical care.

Wendy

6 Likes

Don’t they fret about giving up “traditional values” to adopt modern ways? Time marches on. Things change. People still like, remember, respect the old ways.

Change is a source of stress. Even when modern ways are better in many ways.

2 Likes