I’m pretty sure I can sell an individual stock and then use that money to buy another individual stock without any financial penalty. Say I bought 5K worth of a stock. It is now worth a little more than what I paid for it. Can I sell the full amount including the gain without tax penalty? Or can I only sell 5K worth? I am not 59 1/2 yet.
Yes, within a Roth, you can sell a stock that has gains (all of it) without a tax penalty. Only if you want to withdraw money would you have a tax event. Selling a stock is not the same as withdrawing money from your account.
Also, the relevant official guidance is at Publication 590-B (2025), Distributions from Individual Retirement Arrangements (IRAs) | Internal Revenue Service
Pete
Hi @Emitfudd,
Just to clarify the @MataroPete quote:
Buying/Selling inside of ANY tax-deferred or tax-free account has No Tax Impact.
The tax impact happens when money/securities are removed from the account by transferring them to a taxable account. This is called a Withdrawal.
Taxes due for traditional IRA’s, traditional 401K’s, etc are all taxed at the income rate.
For withdrawals from Roth accounts, no tax of any kind is due as long as the the withdrawal is Qualified according to 590-B.
Just to reiterate, buying/selling inside of the account has No Tax Impact.
Does that help you?
Gene
All holdings and some statistics on my Fool profile page
Profile - gdett2 - Motley Fool Community (Click Expand)
Sorry, that’s not completely true.
If you sell for a loss in a taxable account, and you buy the identical investment in a retirement account within 30 days before or after the loss in the taxable account was generated, you have created a wash sale. Because of the wash sale, you cannot recognize the loss in the taxable account. Worse, the basis adjustment occurs on the investment you purchased in the retirement account, where you will never really be able to recognize it, because retirement accounts are not taxed on their capital gains and losses - just on the withdrawals.
Another scenario which can generate taxes for a retirement account is having a retirement account that owns MLPs, private equity investments, real estate or other investments that can generate UBTI, generally when a sale of the investment occurs. (With 401(k)s now being allowed to invest in private equity, this issue may be more likely to occur.) If investments in a retirement account generate more than $1000 in UBTI in any year, the retirement account itself has to file a tax return. The UBTI income is not passed through to tax return of the owner of the retirement account, but is instead, recognized on a tax return for the retirement account, and taxed at the generally higher trust tax rates.
Both of these scenarios are uncommon, but they do occur.
AJ