Should the US take a Lesson from France?

France hasn’t run a balanced budget in more than 30 years.

France’s borrowing costs are surging as investors around the world wake up to the risk of a full-blown public debt crisis in the EU’s second-largest economy.

Stress in financial markets has now started to spread beyond its borders, raising fears that political dysfunction in France could cause a broader, regional problem.

Investor concerns about France’s fiscal and political impasse have ballooned.

For many years, investors considered Germany and France as roughly equivalent credits: The premium they demanded to hold 10-year French bonds over comparable German ones was measured in pennies. But since the pandemic, and more recently since President Emmanuel Macron’s disastrous gamble on early elections two years ago, it has started to increase — first gradually, now suddenly.

In absolute terms, the French 10-year bond yield is nearly at 5 percent, the highest it’s been since 2008.

It seems France’s macroeconomic situation is unraveling.

2 Likes

French voters seem unwilling to accept reduced govt spending — most recently raise retirement age. Now they pay the price. Using the Euro means they cannot inflate currency. Higher interest rates might be one of the few ways to educate voters.

1 Like

About sex and cooking but not much else. :fork_and_knife_with_plate:

The Captain

5 Likes

70% of their electricity from nuclear power. As such, they are a net exporter of electric power to the UK, Germany, Italy…

_ Pete

10 Likes

Electricity Exports By Country 2026

  1. France
  2. Germany
  3. Switzerland
  4. Sweden
    Electricity Exports By Country 2026 - Rankings & Map | StatsPanda
3 Likes

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/06/world/europe/france-protests-social-welfare-election.html?unlocked_article_code=1.GlE.X7IC.LIxZ-TZ-ejn2

France suddenly finds itself engulfed by crisis — not a single spasm of unrest, but a cascade of disruption that is roiling city streets, trading floors and public offices across the country. France’s “rentrée,” or “return,” as the French call the back-to-school and back-to-work season, has been anything but orderly.

While the causes of the chaos may appear disparate, they can be traced to a common root: France’s two-decade-long struggle to fund its state, now exacerbated by high borrowing costs, surging fuel prices and political uncertainty, with jockeying underway to replace President Emmanuel Macron next spring.

French public finances, already fragile, continue to deteriorate, fanning fears in financial markets that France could be the next European country to tumble into a full-blown financial crisis. The fiscal jitters were amplified by recent polls that show the far-right candidate, Marine Le Pen, would beat all her rivals in presidential elections that will be held next spring.

On Tuesday, teachers and other public workers rallied against proposed wage freezes as the government labors to pass a budget. They joined thousands of students who have blockaded schools to protest underfunding that has led to crumbling facilities and a shortage of teachers.

With images of young protesters clashing with the police amid clouds of tear gas, the student protests have become the most vivid manifestation of France’s unrest and grievances. Hundreds of schools around the country have closed, dozens have been damaged, and many people have been arrested or injured.

France, of course, is no stranger to social unrest, most recently the yellow-vest protests, which raged between 2018 and 2020. Tens of thousands of people, wearing high-visibility safety vests, turned out for weekly demonstrations that began as a protest against rising fuel prices and grew into demands for political and economic justice.

energy prices are only one piece of France’s precarious fiscal picture. The country’s public debt stands at roughly $4 trillion, which is 119 percent of its annual economic output. With rates on French government bonds spiking, the cost of servicing that debt is projected to increase to roughly $100 billion in 2027.

On top of that, France faces higher health care and pension costs because of its aging population, as well as increased military spending driven by the war in Ukraine and the disengagement of the United States.

The fundamental problem in France seems to be slow growth of the economy. Unable to keep up with voter demand. Now rising energy costs. Not much success cutting costs. Not much success stimulating growth. Looks like they are in for hard times.

And in France that means lots of unrest. Leaders have not forgotten the power of the people to let heads roll during the French Revolution.

What is the solution?

I would guess removal of many migrants and then changing rules to increase productivity and reducing benefits slightly, or perhaps freezing benefits for five to ten years,

Jk

I would hope not. You imagine if they did? We don’t for very good reasons.

Capitalism?

The Captain

1 Like

Democracy depends on voters making good choices. If they make bad choices, the consequences can be severe. Capitalism responds w penalties but cannot overcome bad choices.

And by the way, notice the people of France have their own solution to the wealth divide. The guillotine works wonders.

2 Likes

It’s why the best of the worst forms of govt are those that protect the minority of one, emphasizing individualism vs collectivism and consolidated state authority.

1 Like

@FOOLME45

While that is something I agree with, there needs to be an understanding that society imposes a cost. That cost can be driven down. In the US, we drive that cost up. The economic times are changing, and we need to drive those costs down. There are efficiencies the government can impart that the public sector can not because of greed and the profit motive in private enterprise.

Or, there are simply services the private sector does not wish to engage in.

I am thinking Universal Care. We are messing around with profit motives. And yes, the greedy do engage in it. It is as cruel to American citizens as it is to the manufacturing costs in the US. We are behind China in part because of private sector costs in healthcare.

1 Like

We’re not behind China in any metrics that matter to me. If the price of healthcare is acceptance of China’s record on human rights, I’ll pass. Imagine living in a society where the govt tells you how many children you can have? How utterly barbaric.

Hmmm. OK, and,

If the price of safe food is acceptance of my dead mother-in-law’s dictums on Kosher while gobbling down Chinese pork ribs (only on Sundays), I’ll fail to see the logical connection, again….

1 Like

Well, sure. But how on Earth does that relate to the cost of healthcare?

1 Like

I’m not sure why we are talking about it in the first place. I thought it was about lessons from France. Unless, one of those lessons is generous welfare programs and open immigration policies are long term incompatible with the economic health of a country.

1 Like

“Give me your tired, your poor,

Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,

The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.

Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,

I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”

3 Likes