Deep American history - Protect government bonds!

I am in the middle of reading “The Hamilton Scheme: An Epic Tale of Money and Power in the American Founding,” by William Hogeland. Naturally, it’s hard to put a 546-page book into a nutshell but it’s so applicable to today’s METAR discussion of Treasuries that I will try.

In a nutshell — protecting the payment of interest on the national debt was key to founding the United States as a federal government instead of a loose confederation of states!

The point was to protect the moneyed interests (which included George Washington and Hamilton himself) while bleeding the small farmers, artisans and workers (which the author calls “the Democracy”). This goes back to before the American Revolution – to the actual financing of the Revolution itself.

We weren’t taught in history class about how the rich in America (as in England) exploited the white working class with high-interest debt until they were little better than slaves. There were rebellions in England over this. In America, before and during the Revolution, there were organized working-class attacks on the wealthy Americans at the same time that Washington was trying to recruit these same men into the revolutionary army against the British.

Skipping the details, the soldiers’ pay (what little there was) was eventually siphoned up by speculators. Hamilton schemed to pay the officers in government debt which put them on the side of protecting this debt. Threat of attack on Congress (pre-Constitution) by the officers was part of the leverage of the Hamilton Scheme.

The complex Hamilton Scheme included absorbing all the States’ debts into one massive federal debt. Then the scheme progressed to taxing liquor producers to come up with the money – the smaller Western liquor producers being hardest hit while the rich liquor producers (Hamilton’s cronies) had large, efficient factories. This resulted in the Whiskey Rebellion.

The bottom line is that the United States has never defaulted on a bond issued by the central government (dating to Continental Congress days). Bond holders got interest payments and the maturing bonds were covered by new bond issuance.

Alexander Hamilton (and his cronies) had a vision of a powerful federal United States which used capital to build profitable factories. (This was the beginning of the Industrial Revolution and the American factories used water power before steam power was invented.)

Hamilton’s vision was fiercely opposed by the states and by Thomas Jefferson. But ultimately Hamilton’s plan of strong banks with paper backed by hard money (from merchant traders) and central government debt prevailed.

It wasn’t until the Civil War that the U.S. absorbed the bank currencies into a single government currency. But that’s a different story.

The absolute safety of interest payments on government debt has been unbroken since before the Constitution was written.

Will it be shaken now?
Wendy

7 Likes

ChatGPT gave a synopsis of how Hamilton’s ideas played out (these seem in line with my American history classes of decades past):

Alexander Hamilton’s financial ideas shaped the trajectory of the United States throughout the 19th century in several key ways:

1. Strengthening Federal Economic Power

Hamilton’s policies established a precedent for a strong federal government with centralized financial control. His vision clashed with Jeffersonian ideals of agrarian democracy, but by the mid-19th century, his approach gained dominance, particularly through industrialization and federal economic intervention.

2. The National Bank and Banking System

  • Hamilton’s First Bank of the United States (1791) was controversial and lasted only until 1811.
  • The Second Bank of the United States (1816–1836) followed similar principles, but Andrew Jackson, a staunch opponent of centralized banking, dismantled it.
  • Despite Jackson’s efforts, Hamilton’s ideas persisted, leading to the eventual creation of the modern banking system, including the Federal Reserve in 1913.

3. Industrialization and Economic Growth

  • Hamilton’s focus on manufacturing and infrastructure development laid the groundwork for the rapid industrial expansion of the 19th century.
  • The rise of railroads, factories, and large-scale financial institutions reflected Hamiltonian economics in action.
  • Tariffs, another Hamiltonian strategy, protected American industries and played a major role in sectional tensions leading to the Civil War.

4. The Civil War and the Triumph of Hamiltonian Economics

  • The war necessitated a strong central government and national financial system, vindicating Hamilton’s policies.
  • The creation of a national currency (the “greenback”) and the establishment of federally chartered banks under the National Banking Acts of 1863 and 1864 were direct extensions of Hamilton’s financial philosophy.
  • Post-war, Republican leaders like Abraham Lincoln and later industrial magnates fully embraced Hamiltonian principles.

5. The Gilded Age and the Rise of Corporate Power

  • Hamilton’s emphasis on finance and industry ultimately contributed to the rise of large corporations and monopolies in the late 19th century.
  • The economic dominance of figures like J.P. Morgan, Andrew Carnegie, and John D. Rockefeller reflected Hamiltonian capitalism.
  • However, this also led to labor struggles, economic inequality, and debates over government regulation—tensions that persist today.

Conclusion

Hamilton’s financial strategies, though initially controversial, became the foundation of the American economic system. While his opponents sought to limit centralized power, the needs of war, industrial expansion, and economic modernization ensured that Hamiltonian principles of banking, industry, and federal economic authority remained dominant throughout the 19th century and beyond.


Pete

4 Likes

I saw a headline on the wire this morning: a proposal to shave a bit off the Federal deficit by escalating payments on student loans. But, of course, I can’t find that piece now.

This piece is a couple weeks old. It may be what the headline I saw this morning was about.

Steve

Billionaires can take a lot of money from poorer folks in a crisis. Every time you sell you’re incurring transaction costs and taxes. Wall Street loves “market timers”. They’re not making any money off “Long-Term Buy & Hold”.

The only leverage the DEMs have at this point is to vote against the debt limit increase ( and stop Gov’t bond interest payments) if Speaker Johnson can’t corral the crazies on his side of the aisle. It’s going to be fun to watch.

intercst

4 Likes

Odds are high that if Congress can’t get their act together, the administration will simply resort to “minting the coin” to cover interest payments and refinancing all the debt that comes due every single week.

Yes because of mismanagement.

Austerity and tax cut will crush our bonds.

A recipe for inflation.
Wendy

3 Likes

Well THAT will sure lower the cost of eggs.

1 Like

Did you say we need to protect government bonds Wendy? Why on Earth would you say that?

https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/trump-says-us-might-have-less-debt-than-thought-2025-02-09/

:frowning: