OT: My medicare choices

Well, M Day is approaching for me. I turn 65 in January, so it was time to make some Medicare decisions. And since I’m delaying Soc Sec until I’m 70, first step was to sign up.

So signing up for Medicare without Social Security is a two step process. Step one is to go to the Social Security web site - ssa.gov - create an account if you haven’t already (I had, and you should, too, just to monitor your Soc Sec account), then sign in and go to the Medicare drop down at the top of the page and sign up. Very quick and straight forward.

About 3 or 4 weeks later, your Medicare card will show up in the mail. And about a week or so after that, I got the bill for the first 3 months of Medicare Part B. Those who are already collecting Soc Sec won’t get a bill - they’ll have the Medicare premium deducted from the Soc Sec benefits.

Then it’s over to the Medicare web site - medicare.gov - to take care of some business there. Top right to sign in or sign up. You can do either from the sign in link.

Now for the trickier stuff. If you do nothing more than the above, you’ll get regular medicare, Parts A (hospital) and B (doctors). But if you want a medicare advantage plan, you’ll need to choose that from the Medicare web site. You can also select other options, such as a drug plan (Part D) , or search for Vision, Dental or Medicare Supplement plans (MediGap).

As to my specific choices, I went with traditional Medicare (Parts A and B) rather than an advantage plan. I also selected a drug plan that was inexpensive (less than $10 a month) and covered all of my routine medicines at 0 cost to me. That was a no-brainer, as the cash price for even my inexpensive generics is way more than the Part D premiums. So I’m guaranteed to save a little money, and if I need some other drug during a year, I’ve got a decent chance at some coverage for that.

Lastly, I went with a Medicare supplement - Plan G with high deductible. I wanted the guaranteed issue of the MediGap plan, and I get a little peace of mind with some caps on larger medical bills. The premium is less than $40 a month for me, but will go up with age. I did check using the medicare web site, and even at age 90, the Supplement plan was something like $70 or $80 a month. So as long as I keep the policy in place, I’ll have some limit on all but the most catastrophic of medical bills.

Almost all of my choices were informed by reading posts here, along with linked articles. To that I added just a bit of my own reading and research. I started reading and learning in earnest about the time I turned 63, so it was a couple years of on and off thinking about the topic.

I’m very comfortable with my choices. After years of worrying about whether a doctor or facility was in network or not, I’m done with that. “Do you take Medicare?” is the only question I need to have answered. I skipped dental and vision. I’ve been paying out of pocket for those for the last 25+ years. Those aren’t going to break my budget. It also helps that I have good genes that gave me good teeth, and I’ve taken good care of those teeth.

So there you have it. One person’s decisions for your education or entertainment or derision. They won’t be right for everyone, but I’m comfortable that they are right enough for me and my situation.

–Peter

21 Likes

Thanks for sharing, Peter. I have 5 years to go, but I like reading about others thought processes and choices on the subject!

3 Likes

Yep. Wellcare’s ValueScript Part D plan is amazing ($0/month premium in my zip code, though I am paying the IRMAA penalty) – brought to you by Medicare’s average $1,700 subsidy for 2026 to the insurer for each Part D plan sold. Since 90% of prescriptions written for seniors are generic, and many don’t take any meds at all, a large portion of the population would be well advised with this choice.

One thing I’ve noticed is that if you’re prescribed anything beside a “preferred generic”, the price gouging is 3 to 5 times the GoodRx price. Make sure to keep WellCare and their Express Scripts PBM on a short leash. {{ LOL }}

intercst

6 Likes

That’s what I’ve got. Just re-checked it - I’m paying $5.70 a month. No zero cost in my zip code. But close enough. I’m on 3 generics, and otherwise reasonably healthy. The choice was a no-brainer.

I was getting O’care for $1 a month. I need something to offset the higher cost of Medicare. :wink: I was paying about $13 a month for my prescriptions.

2 Likes

Thanks for the walk through. I will start Medicare in April 2026, and like you, won’t be taking social security until age 70. I expect my choices will look about exactly like yours…

Tim

3 Likes

If you are collecting Social Security, Medicare is automatic when you qualify. But that is basic Medicare coverage. Supplemental, Part D, or Medicare Advantage are optional. You have to select those.

1 Like

Isn’t it the reverse of that? A catastrophic $1 million or $10 million illness is capped at about $3,000 out-of -pocket for the year. You’ll be paying the 20% co-pay on the small stuff until you reach the $3,000 annual limit.

In WA State, we have Community Rating, so whether you’re age 65 or 105 you pay the same $48/month premium. WA State also gives current Medigap policy holders a year round open enrollment period.

If United American is no longer the low cost provider, I can quickly switch to whatever company offers the lowest premium.

intercst

5 Likes

Did you look into MSAs? Medicare Savings Accounts? Read an article about a month ago talking about how it is a little known little used option. I didn’t know about it.

Anyway, I still have 4 years to go and plenty of rules and regulations can change by then.

I did not. They’re only available with a Medicare Advantage plan, and I did not want an Advantage plan.

2 Likes

You did better than me. I was swindled out of $1.42/month the last two years I was on Obamacare before I reached age 65.

But I did get a rebate check for $632 because my for-profit insurer failed to spend the required minimum of 80% of premiums collected on actual medical care for policyholders.

It happens rarely, but sometimes the “skim” works in your favor.

intercst

2 Likes

I’m not sure I really did better. It wasn’t due to good planning - I simply don’t have a lot of income. My actual figures were 74 cents and 71 cents a month for 2024 and 2025. But when my 2024 return was done, I had to kick in another roughly $210 because the monthly subsidy was a bit too much. I’m expecting a similar result for 2025. So let’s call it $20 a month for health insurance once all is said and done. Still a darn good deal.

Back in 2019 and 2020, Obamacare was still charging you for the cost of “reproductive healthcare” which by law the tax subsidy couldn’t cover. It didn’t matter how low your income was, the minimum premium appeared to be $1.42/month.

Which is crazy. A private employer plan that doesn’t cover contraception and abortion actually has a higher monthly premium than one that does. Birthing a baby is much more expensive than providing contraception.

intercst

1 Like