It is a shame we lost all the earlier posts on this name.
Lumber prices are declining and at this level soon lumber manufacturers will not be making money and they will start cutting production. Alternatively China demand may pickup, btw, it has never really recovered post COVID. I am not sure the industry has an ability to adjust quickly. We need to see.
WY stock price is slowly declining and it is at 3 year low. WY has increased its revenue streams but their primary business is lumber and if the prices goes down it will impact them.
If $WY gets closer to $20, I will be a buyer. I am not expecting it to happen quickly, it will be like watching paint dry or if you prefer, watching the trees grow, in Southern US trees typically grow for 20~25 years before they are ready for harvesting for saw logs and in Western US (my backyard Washington) it can grow up to 30 to 40 years. So patience is not a virtue but a basic requirement in this business.
China manufacturing is weak, PMI @ 49.1, employment and raw material inventory are at contractionary territory. Yet across the world for ex: Brazil new capacity are coming online.
The price moved up to $30. The below 5 year chart shows a strong support around $27.5 and resistance around $35.
There was a period I used to trade stocks in range, no longer. REIT’s often trade in ranges and generally I was successful trading them in range. However, option bid-ask is so wide, that makes using options suboptimal. So you have to buy the stock, collect the dividend and get out near the upper range and then wait again patiently.
For those who enjoy clipping coupons, these are good ideas.
Interesting that you mention WY in the context of clipping coupons.
Got into their 7-3/8 of '32 back in '08 at 69 and change for a projected YTM of 10.7%. Got into their 7-7/8 of '26 the same year at 64 and change for a projected YTM of 12.6%.
And I agree that those kinds of opportunities still exist if one knows where to look and is willing to do the needed due diligence and to accept the obvious risks.
The lumber prices rose from July bottom and along with that the stock price moved up and now lumber price is rolling over and the stock is declining.
WY, showed how difficult for the lumber companies to reduce the harvest, they guided for 4Q the timber harvest will be reduced 35.5 mn tons to 34.5 mn tons, that is less than 3% reduction.
The industry and WY in particular faces headwinds that they can hardly control:
Housing demand
China Demand
Regulatory issues, currently China has excluded retaliatory tariffs on lumber, so it can remove that exclusion anytime; Don’t blame china, blame US policy on this.
On the positive side,
Their lumber and wood products neutralize each other in pricing cycles;
WY has strong balance sheet
reduced dividend commitment, i.e., before 2020, they had slightly over $1 B in dividend payout; now they switched to fixed+variable; This is still hefty ($600 M) in committed dividend and the rest is based on FAD generation
The timberland recycling resulting in better timber holdings
Lastly, they own 10 m timberland, valuing at $2000 per acre (note they have different types and in different geography, I am just using a short-hand here), that is worth $20 B, then they have wood products division and $5 B in long-term debt. The cash on hand is equal to various other liabilities and a wash. So one has to be patient to enter at the right price. This is not your typical growth company… here things take decades to grow!!! OTOH, the land, and timber are true store of value!
WY has 7 million acres in the US South. WY has $45 per acre EBITDA on the south, compared to the industry average of $60. These trends cannot be reversed quickly, as this involves location (closer to mills, ports), silviculture (higher yield plants, species, etc), age of the stock, etc. However, this is a long-term potential. If they can get this to the industry average that would be 35% increase or $100 M higher EBITDA. Of course it will take time, given their size they may not be able to optimize and they may never catch up.
Separately, in PNW (WA & OR) WY has the industry leading EBITDA per acre.
While in the short-term it is a headwind, in the long-term it is a tail-wind. US has a housing shortage and aging housing inventory. How it is going to address is to be seen. However it is a tailwind for timber REIT’s and home improvement duopoly.
After reviewing Q4, Q1-2025 and overall 2025 guidance, nothing much has changed. 2 items of note are:
they announced a $500M new timberstrand facility, expected to be completed and operational by 2027
Cost overrun, project delays is a concern, also capex takes away cash otherwise available for buyback.
Timberstrand is typically produced from Hardwood, and $WY is trying to produce this from Southern yellow pine, which is a softwood lumber; We need to see whether market embraces this; but there is that acceptance risk.
Announced natural climate solutions did $84 M EBITDA and expect $100M EBITDA
This is a nice development for the company; However, with the current administration, the ability to monetize carbon credits is a risk; Having said that $TSLA makes significant money from the monetization;
Challenging 2024 didn’t offer any opportunity with the stock price. Will wait…
Q1 is okay, and Q2 guidance is bit weak. Lumber demand is weak (Due to residential construction and commercial construction), prices are weak. Tariffs to have some impact. Unless the demand for Lumber improves, this stock is not going anywhere in hurry for sometime.
For now, I have Oct $22 puts sold. If they are assigned I will take.
