"Excess elites" in China

The historian Peter Turchin has written several fascinating books that are essential to understanding Macroeconomic cycles. My favorite is “Secular Cycles.”

Turchin coined the phrase “excess elites” to describe people in the prosperous phase of an economic cycle who have been raised to expect that they will have great opportunities…but there are more people than opportunities. In the medieval context this would include younger aristocratic sons who won’t inherit lands. In the modern context they would include college-educated youth whose economies can’t provide the jobs they trained for.

Turchin says that excess elites can be highly destabilizing to society. They are educated and can provide the theoretical basis for the masses to incite revolution.

https://www.wsj.com/economy/global/chinas-xi-calls-for-more-jobs-for-young-people-migrant-workers-7c0ab230?mod=economy_lead_pos1

China’s Xi Calls for More Jobs for Young People, Migrant Workers

Official data pegged the youth jobless rate at 14.7% in April

May 29, 2024

China’s president is urging officials to create more jobs for young people and migrant workers…Employment for young people including fresh graduates is a top priority…

For the record-high nearly 12 million college graduates set to enter China’s job market this year, landing a job will likely be tough. Official data pegged the youth jobless rate at 14.7% in April…

The problem isn’t that China doesn’t have jobs for the youth, economists say. The issue is structural imbalances in the job market.

Many factories struggle to find enough workers to keep production lines humming as the population ages, while low-paid service sectors such as housekeeping find it hard to attract employees. There is also a shortage of the better-paid, high-skilled jobs many young people want to land after years of studying… [end quote]

This is pretty much the definition of excess elites. The Chinese leadership is aware of the problem and trying to solve it. But it isn’t easy to generate high-skill-level jobs.

Wendy

4 Likes

The medieval elites launched the crusades as the perfect fix for excess elite kids. The crucial fact is that they almost certainly did NOT do this conscientiously, but the random jab worked well within the circumstances and so a succession of crusades bled off the excess kids (and the black death and some other stuff helped).

With that as precedent I say Yich!.

d fb

1 Like

I hope the Chinese don’t use that example to invade Taiwan with their million-man army.
Wendy

1 Like

A bad war, with many losses of young men, would make their demographic problem even worse. Another reason why the Russia war is serving as a lesson to China.

4 Likes

Although they do have an excess of men, a result of the one-child policy.

DB2

4 Likes

Just to quibble, is it really an excess or more of an imbalance? They have a shortage of all youth, just less so of men. Correct? They can’t really afford to lose either.

Cool graph:

2 Likes

I thought of this while posting the above, but most demographers seem to think that their overall demographic problem (a large multi-decade gap of sufficient population growth) is far worse than their bad male to female ratio (which is also a problem).

1 Like

That is an argument for supporting Xi staying in power. The next guy might rise to power just to invade Taiwan. That should not surprise us.

The US invasion of Iraq was to get oil to China. This allowed China to industrialize but not militarize as soon. Very purposeful policy on our part. It was never explained to the American public. There were papers on preemptive war for this purpose. The NYTs and WaPo never discussed reality.

DB2

1 Like