Germany: Gas Can't Rely on Canada

I suppose they will have to go to Vlad on bended knee in hopes he won’t do what he probably wants to do?

Germany spent decades digging themselves into this mess … and now the politicians are looking around for someone else to blame? Our new friends in Ukraine would prefer we don’t send it back … as would our big neighbor to the south and many other countries that have been unfriended by Putin.

Good thing they still have the lignite mines and associated power plants Eh!

Don’t get me wrong here. I like the German people … just happen to think their coalition form of government encourages a lot of political nonsense and fibbing.

Anymouse

https://www.bnnbloomberg.ca/germany-s-drive-to-replace-russi…

COMMODITIES 3h ago

Germany’s drive to replace Russian gas can’t rely on Canada

Michael Nienaber, Bloomberg News

5 Likes

German voters seem to be the source of the problem. They made risky choices that turned out negative.

Such is the nature of politics. It happens everywhere.

A well educated public is the best we can do, but that is not always effective.

1 Like

Don’t get me wrong here. I like the German people … just happen to think their coalition form of government encourages a lot of political nonsense and fibbing.

Doesn’t appear to be unique to Germany. Or coalition forms of government, for that matter.

AW

2 Likes

Doesn’t appear to be unique to Germany. Or coalition forms of government, for that matter.

Right! Politicians are experts at creating unintended consequences with their utopian stupidities.

What is Seen and What is Not Seen, or Political Economy in One Lesson1 [July 1850] [final edit]

Frédéric Bastiat explained it to the world 17 decades ago but who is smart enough to learn the lesson?

https://oll.libertyfund.org/page/wswns

The Captain

2 Likes

Fiction: I suppose they will have to go to Vlad on bended knee in hopes he won’t do what he probably wants to do?

===============================

Fact: Germans will never beg Russia for anything. Germans will take care of their energy needs without Russian if needed.

Jaak

Germany’s drive to replace Russian gas can’t rely on Canada

====================================================================

LOL! Of course Canada can not supply LNG to anyone in Europe!

Aug 17, 2022

Canada does not have LNG terminals capable of supplying Germanyy. Currently, there are no LNG export terminals operating in Canada. One terminal is under construction — the Shell-led LNG Canada project in Kitimat, B.C. — and there has been heightened pressure on Canada to deliver export capacity in Atlantic Canada amid a deepening energy crisis in Europe.

https://financialpost.com/commodities/energy/oil-gas/report-…

But Germany could receive LNG from Qatar as early as 2024, sheikh tells Handelsblatt.

https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/germany-could-receiv…

BERLIN, May 20 (Reuters) - Qatar hopes to start sending liquefied natural gas (LNG) to Germany in 2024, the Gulf state’s deputy prime minister told the German daily Handelsblatt on Friday.

German plans to set up LNG terminals are picking up speed as the country scrambles to wean itself off cheaper gas imports piped from Russia in response to Moscow’s attack on Ukraine.

Jaak

Meanwhile —Germans are moving forward with a plan…besides calling for a 15% reduction of gas use …floating LNG import terminals will take in LNG end of this year/early 2023…

Germany in May leased four floating storage and regasification units (FSRUs) for the import of at least 5 billion cubic metres a year each of seaborne gas, of which two are due to become available this year.

https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/germanys-lng-import-…

https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/germany-says-fifth-f…

from US DOE:

Germany was the largest consumer of natural gas in Europe in 2019, consuming 8.6 billion cubic feet per day (Bcf/d) of natural gas.

https://www.eia.gov/international/analysis/country/DEU

As Russian gas became the most cost effective, German demand from Netherlands and Norway faded. Germany has not had LNG import terminals until now. Norway gas comes to Germany direct from North Sea extraction and processing platforms through 3 different pipelines. Most northwestern European countries are also all connected with Germany.

Netherlands is the gas price hub (title transfer) for Euro area but other countries, particularly France and Spain have the multiple import facilities (18-20B cu m/yr). Netherlands has one at 12Bcum…that’s unload/regasification capacity on an annual basis. My calculation (double checked) for Germany demand at 8.6Bcf/day is 88B cu meters annually. Other reports - probably more accurate say it imports 100B cu m annually. 32% in 2021 from Russia.

So the first two FSRU (Floating Storage Regasification Units) at 5B each covers 11% of need. The 3rd unit is said to be operable by YE 2023 and the fourth no until 2026 if I read correctly. So Germany still has a problem:

100B demand 2021
32B from Russia
-15B reduction from forced limitation / coal maybe even oil (diesel) use for industrial heat / power…if this is feasible…
-10B from these new LNG tankers
= 7B (7%) hurdle in winter 22/23.

So maybe from Netherlands and Norway increases they may make it.

Meanwhile USA exports, hurt by Freeport LNG explosion/fire, come back to full capacity in October. Currently in 2022 (Freeport fire in January 22) we’ve been running 9ish BCF/D. In January our production was 11.2BCF/da or so with short term capability of 14BCF/D. At full capacity using 360 da/year (5 for maintenance) we have 113Bcu meters annual capability - enough if Germany had the import facilities.

For perspective USA produced 934Bcu m natural gas in 2021 (2.3% increase YoY vs last 10 years 4.4%/yr growth) so 10-12% is being made into LNG.

We are the largest (for now) exporter of LNG with our 5 large and 2 small production / terminals. There is one additional train coming on-line at Freeport later in 2023. Qatar Petroleum (largest single company LNG producer at 106Bcu m in 2021) and others (Algeria & Nigeria) are not standing still. I’ve read elsewhere that the Germans have multiple suppliers in view for these FSRU’s. Worldwide there is 516Bcm LNG production capacity on-line now. Australia is largest in Asia (108Bcum)

Through June of this year, the U.S exported about 57 bcm of gas as LNG with 39 bcm, or 68%, going to Europe, Refinitiv data shows. That is compared with 34 bcm, or 35%, of LNG exports shipped to Europe for all of 2021.

https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/us-lng-exports-europ…

Some interesting total energy use stats by BP economist here, LNG on pg 38:

https://www.bp.com/content/dam/bp/business-sites/en/global/c…

Joe
Community Fool
click link for my profile & holdings
http://my.fool.com/profile/CMFJambo/info.aspx

2 Likes

Some interesting total energy use stats by BP economist here, LNG on pg 38:

=======================================

Great post. Proves that Canada does not export any LNG to anyone in the world. So the OP is a bad joke.

Jaak

The long term plans to build two LNG export terminals on the East coast kept running into obstacles from various levels of government. Eventually the company “Pieridae” just gave up. Two bad as the location would have had a far faster turn around than anything coming from the US Gulf coast.

Tim

https://www.bnnbloomberg.ca/east-coast-lng-solution-achievab…

COMMODITIES Aug 19, 2022

East coast LNG solution ‘achievable’ – just not any time soon: Pieridae

Michelle Zadikian, BNN Bloomberg

Cur­rent sta­tus of gas sup­ply in Ger­many

Status report (as at: 1 pm, 22 August 2022)

  • Since 23 June 2022 the alert level of the gas emergency plan has been in place.
  • The situation is tense and a further worsening of the situation cannot be ruled out. The gas supply in Germany is, however, currently stable. At present, the security of supply in Germany continues to be safeguarded.
  • Gas flows from Nord Stream 1 are currently at about 20% of maximum capacity.
  • Gas continues to be injected into storage. The total storage level in Germany is 79.5%. The storage level at the Rehden facility is 60.4%.
  • Most recently, wholesale prices have increased to a very high level as a result of the latest reduction in supply.
  • Companies and private consumers must expect a considerable increase in gas prices.

https://www.bundesnetzagentur.de/EN/Areas/Energy/Companies/S….

Jaak

So the OP is a bad joke.

I’m going from memory here, but I’m pretty sure the German reliance on Canada has to do with a piece of Russian pipeline equipment sent to Canada for repair and refurbishment. That equipment got stuck in Canada due to sanctions after the Russian invasion of Ukraine.

That equipment is needed to get Russian gas to Germany.

It never had anything to do with Canadian gas exports to Germany, of which there are apparently none.

–Peter

1 Like

Agree - if Russia ever returns to grace with the West, transport cost will be a thing. They also have BIG LNG new facility at Yamal on the Arctic - increasingly navigable.

Joe