Control Panel: Show me the money!

As a risk-averse investor, 38Packard wondered how much cash is on the sidelines. Cash is money that is liquid – it can be spent immediately and is not tied up in time deposits, bonds, stocks, real estate or other less-liquid investments.

M1, the liquid money supply, is currently $20.5 Trillion. This compares with GDP at $24.8 Trillion.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1SL
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/GDP

That’s a lotta cash. But saying it’s “on the sidelines” implies that the owners of this cash could be tempted to buy assets such as stocks with it. Obviously, that’s not the case.

The total market capitalization of the U.S. stock market was about $48 Trillion on March 31st, 2022.
https://siblisresearch.com/data/us-stock-market-value/

U.S. fixed income markets, including U.S. Treasuries, mortgage-backed securities (MBS), corporate bonds, municipal securities, federal agency securities, asset-backed securities (ABS), and money markets is $52.9 Trillion.

https://www.sifma.org/resources/research/statistics/us-fixed…

The value of the stock market is supported by debt (margin buying). Currently, margin debt is about $700 billion. Not coincidentally, margin debt rose in 2020 - 2021 as the stock market bubble formed. It peaked and has dropped since 12/31/2021. This let some of the air out of the bubble but the level of margin is still high on a historic basis.

https://ycharts.com/indicators/finra_margin_debt

The USD is at a generational high.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/for-wall-street-a-strong-dollar…

**For Wall Street, a Strong Dollar Is Front and Center**
**Investors are increasingly concerned that the rising U.S. currency will strain other economies**
**By Julia-Ambra Verlaine, The Wall Street Journal, Sept. 11, 2022**

**...**
**Investors and policy makers are being forced to consider history’s unkind lessons. Currency shifts were behind the 1997 Asian financial crisis and played a role in the Russian financial crisis of 1998, which took down giant U.S. hedge fund Long-Term Capital Management....**

**A stronger dollar often makes emerging-markets currencies less valuable. That in turn exacerbates inflation in those countries, by making it more expensive to import goods and services.**

**Earlier this year, emerging markets remained resilient even as the dollar rallied. But that was largely because commodities prices were rising, boosting countries that export copper, soybeans and coffee. Now commodities prices are falling, and global economists say trouble could lie ahead for emerging markets....U.S. corporations involved in international business have cut earnings guidance since June, citing the dollar’s gains....** [end quote]

The Federal Reserve’s swift tightening is one reason that the dollar has soared this year. Foreign investors are attracted to relatively high Treasury debt yields and are exchanging their own currencies to buy dollars in order to buy Treasuries.

At the same time, the Fed is beginning to sell Treasuries and mortgage debt that were bought as an emergency measure during 2020. This is Quantitative Tightening, or QT. It’s just a tiny fraction so far but the pace will double this month. Starting this month, the Fed will allow up to $60 billion of Treasuries and $35 billion of mortgage bonds to roll off its balance sheet as the debts come due, twice as much as the past three months.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WALCL

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/11/business/fed-treasury-mar…

**Fed’s Exit Puts World’s Biggest Bond Market on Shakier Ground**

**Some traders worry that the $25 trillion U.S. Treasury market is becoming more fragile, and the Federal Reserve’s removal of support could make it worse.**
**By Joe Rennison, The New York Times, Sept. 11, 2022**

**...**

**Even small wobbles in the Treasury market can generate huge worries. At its worst, a Treasury trading breakdown could cause the value of the dollar, stocks and other bonds to tumble. Economies that borrow a lot in dollars and hold Treasuries in their reserves would teeter. Crucially, the U.S. government could find it hard to finance itself, even up to defaulting on its debt, the financial equivalent of an earthquake.**

**“While this sounds like a bad science-fiction movie, it is unfortunately a real threat,” Ralph Axel, an interest rate strategist at Bank of America, wrote in a research report last week. He sees emerging strains in the Treasury market as “the single greatest systemic financial risk today,” with the potential to do more damage than the housing turmoil that preceded the 2008 financial crisis....**

**The Treasury market has doubled over the past decade, to around $25 trillion, as the government’s financing needs have grown. All that debt needs to be bought by someone, and not just the Fed....** [end quote]

The Treasury yield curve has risen consistently over the past few months. Interest rates will probably continue to rise as a combination of the rising fed funds rate and QT. If inflation doesn’t subside, the market’s forward estimate of inflation could rise, adding further upward pressure to yields.

The markets showed a slight turn toward more risk-on, as stock markets and junk bonds rose relative to the UST. Oil and natgas prices dropped slightly. The Fear & Greed Index was Neutral.

The METAR for next week is partly sunny. The markets are uncertain and could quickly turn around but for the very short term the stock market has stabilized.

Wendy

https://stockcharts.com/freecharts/candleglance.html?VTI,$SP…

https://stockcharts.com/freecharts/candleglance.html?$IRX,$U…

https://stockcharts.com/freecharts/candleglance.html?$SPX,$U…

https://www.cnn.com/markets/fear-and-greed

https://stockcharts.com/freecharts/yieldcurve.php

Wendy

15 Likes

Investors are increasingly concerned that the rising U.S. currency will strain other economies

One of the main reasons the dollar is strong is that other economies are strained. 60% of the dollar index is based on the euro. Does anybody think Europe’s economy is going to be healthy this winter?

DB2

3 Likes

Hi Wendy,

Thanks for the links to the St Louis Fed and other reports. I’m going through your post in more detail to better understand how folks are stockpiling cash and ran across this article that describes why the graph in your first link (M1) has skyrocketed since 2021. (They changed the definition of M1 to include savings accounts now)

https://fredblog.stlouisfed.org/2021/05/savings-are-now-more…

I’m still a bit unclear as to how to more accurately define money that is sitting on the sidelines in investment accounts that is in a liquid position - ready to be deployed into equities when the time is right.

I agree that it’s not M1, but another monetary metric “Other Liquid Deposits” may be close - currently at $13.4 Trillion.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MDLM#0

Other liquid deposits consist of negotiable order of withdrawal and automatic transfer service balances at depository institutions, share draft accounts at credit unions, demand deposits at thrift institutions, and savings deposits, including money market deposit accounts.

Thanks again for the links and info. I’m going to meet with a guy from Fidelity later this week - maybe I’ll bring this up in our conversation.

'38Packard

1 Like

38packard
I’m still a bit unclear as to how to more accurately define money that is sitting on the sidelines…

I also had difficulty understanding how anyone can discern the investment intent of all of the people controlling the M1 (or any other) pile of cash:

wendy:
But saying it’s “on the sidelines” implies that the owners of this cash could be tempted to buy assets such as stocks with it. Obviously, that’s not the case.

Does anyone know how we can claim cash holders are obviously tempted or not tempted to act in some particular way?

Are there data to back this assertion of the mindset of some group of market participants?

2 Likes

<Are there data to back this assertion of the mindset of some group of market participants? >

$944 billion in personal savings. I looked up the number with the BEA. This appears to be savings accounts, not investments in assets. It’s possible that some of the personal savings could be shifted into assets. Please feel free to do further research.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PSAVE

56% of American adults, or about 145 million people, own stock. But the Wealthiest 10% Own More Than 80%.
https://www.fool.com/research/how-many-americans-own-stock/

I think it’s fair to say that at least some of the 44% of American adults who do not own stock probably do own banking and checking accounts. These are not market participants.

Wendy

3 Likes

Does anyone know how we can claim cash holders are obviously tempted or not tempted to act in some particular way?

I don’t know about the rest of the world but I have some money in bank accounts that will not be used to buy assets. It’s the cash reserve for emergencies and market crashes.

How to prevent selling at the wrong time and trying to buy back in at the right time? Have a sufficient cash reserve so you don’t feel the need to sell and then you won’t have the need to buy back in.

KISS!

The Captain

4 Likes

$944 billion in personal savings.

That is often the emergency money. It generally is not going into stocks. Not when the market tanks.

Even small wobbles in the Treasury market can generate huge worries. At its worst, a Treasury trading breakdown could cause the value of the dollar, stocks and other bonds to tumble. Economies that borrow a lot in dollars and hold Treasuries in their reserves would teeter. Crucially, the U.S. government could find it hard to finance itself, even up to defaulting on its debt, the financial equivalent of an earthquake.


For each trade there is a counter-party. Nothing less will satisfy some people than low interest rates, low inflation, high stock market and high value to the USD and sunny weather. Unfortunately there are mathematical linkages which make that combinate highly improbable. That then creates teams who root for each outcome - to the expense of other groups.

Jeff

1 Like

$944 billion in personal savings. I looked up the number with the BEA. This appears to be savings accounts, not investments in assets. It’s possible that some of the personal savings could be shifted into assets. Please feel free to do further research.

How is the $944 billion in personal savings informing us about the sentiment of the owners of the M1 money supply of $20.5 trillion (a $19 trillion difference, by the way)?
This assertion was about M1.
wendy:
M1, the liquid money supply, is currently $20.5 Trillion. …
That’s a lotta cash. But saying it’s “on the sidelines” implies that the owners of this cash could be tempted to buy assets such as stocks with it. Obviously, that’s not the case.

In what way can we conclude from these data that the sentiment (either tempted or not tempted to buy stocks) of the owners of M1 is obvious?

M1 (https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1SL)
Personal Savings (https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PSAVE)

Sometimes it seems there is a narrative in mind, and then a link to data with a claim that the data support the narrative or a change in data under discussion. For example, see these responses by others.
https://discussion.fool.com/the-markets-have-a-hissy-fit-with-ev…
https://discussion.fool.com/fed-chair-powell-clearly-believes-th…
https://discussion.fool.com/i-think-it39s-plain-wrong-that39s-wh…

2 Likes