Consumer sentiment is a contrarian bullish signal

There are serious of consumer surveys, media reports to SeekingAlpha screaming how investors are shell shocked and the market is going to crash, etc.

We don’t know what the market is going to do, but all this negativity is a strong contrarian signal.

1 Like

Here is another data point showing, the negative sentiments are truly historical now.

Meh.

AAII bears was also above 50% for 4 straight weeks in the summer of 2008.

And, for full disclosure, they were also above 50% for 4 straight weeks in late February of 2009.

Not sure I would necessarily put much stock into this when there are so few periods of 4 or 5 straight weeks above 50%.

So what you are saying during a severe market decline, a period where markets declined by 50%, I think the market bottomed on March 9th, and when people were literally jumping out of the office window, and nation underwent a serious housing crisis, that is people were losing houses, biggest wall street firms were going under, congress has to pass multiple bailout packages… we didn’t hit 5 weeks in row. But now we are hitting is something you will ignore. I present a data, how you want to look at it, and consume it is up to you.

Here is the problem. When the market has 3 waves down at the bottom of each wave the bearish sentiment is high then it goes up to a lower high when everyone gets bullish and then drops again. Those are both bear and bull traps. Everyone gets chopped up. So be careful when trying to decide when the final drop is. This is a very tricky market.

2 Likes

What validity do you assign to five weeks that you don’t assign to 4 weeks?

Again, it was above 50% in the summer of 2008. Those bears were absolutely correct.

I am not going to assign some value that might be simply be coincidence. For example, maybe the real correlation is not five weeks above 50 but being above 60% for 3 weeks.

Having just two times (as far as we know from this thread) when it was five weeks straight above 50 in the last 30+ years is not a trend for me to buy and sell on. If you feel that one additional week somehow is a panacea for investing (but 4 weeks is not), then feel free.

Apple with its 7% and 9% weight in SP500 and Nasdaq100, is showing a very positive price action. Again, use multiple indicators to see how the market is acting.

I agree with looking at individual stocks. It’s possible to find a good one hiding out among all the poor ones.

That’s not what I said, when the Apple moves that moves 10% of the market cap, market cannot go down or up without big stocks going with them. Hence, Apple performance is important to watch. If you are going to look at individual names, they cannot be such an anchor to the overall market. You can substitute apple with Mag7.

:joy: That’s what makes the market

Oh then I disagree. Because the market is heading down and I suspect we will get a dead cat bounce around 17490 then I expect it to take out the lows of 3 /11

OpenAI is close to finalizing $40B funding round!!! AI trade is not yet done…

In a normal distribution, 68% of observations will fall within 1 standard deviation (1 sigma) and 95% within 2 standard deviation and 99.7% within 3 standard deviation. Now, you should be able to do the math yourself.