Wpr101's May 2024 portfolio review

At the end of May 2024 my portfolio is,

Super Micro (SMCI) - 19.2%
AppLovin (APP) - 17.6%
Nvidia (NVDA) - 17.1%
Elf (ELF) - 15.4%
Hims & Hers Health (HIMS) - 15.2%
Transmedics (TMDX) - 13.8%
Celsius (CELH) - 1.6%

The biggest changes I made were to increase my position in HIMS and APP, and concentrate my holdings into my top six positions. I sold AXON and mostly sold CELH.


I discovered a great book on investing this month called Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits by Philip A. Fisher. It’s a surprisingly timeless book because a huge portion of the book is about finding companies with superior R&D and superior sales teams, there was a lot of great information on how to determine if a company has a superior research team. One of the key takeaways was that you want to find companies which can keep innovating past their current product lines.

Another interesting aspect of this book was lengthy discussions about the semiconductor industries. This is a quite old book and he was writing about companies such as Texas Instruments and why he liked this company. He even wrote something along the lines of I expect there to be another semiconductor boom in the late 1980s that will pale in comparison to the current one. And here we are today in the midst of another semiconductor boom cycle that looks to surpass all the previous ones.


Reviewing the companies I own,

Super Micro - 19.2%
I wrote some thoughts about the JP Morgan technology conference and their latest earnings.

While the stock was down a bit after their earnings I thought this was a great report and they raised their next quarter’s revenue guidance by 400M. The more I learn about this company the more I like. They have very deep and long standing relationships with Nvidia, AMD, and Intel. Interestingly both Nvidia and Supermicro were founded in 1993 and both Jensen and Charles Liang are immigrants from Taiwan and their friendship predates the founding of the companies. Supermicro’s Youtube channel has interviews with AMD CEO and with Intel’s CEO. I’m pleased to see how deep these relationships are with the key players in the industry.

I recently learned that Supermicro actually already has a manufacturing plant in Asia in Taiwan, one in Netherlands, and one is Silicon Valley. This is in addition the new Malaysia facility which comes online soon. The following square footage of the facilities gives some idea of the capacity of the factories,

Taiwan - 2M sqft
Netherlands - 800k sqft
Silicon Valley - 2M sqft
Malaysia - unknown

Another thing which has given me confidence on this position is the incredible amount of research the company publishes and puts on their website through webinars and white papers.

Something key I learned from one of the webinars is that future Hopper and Blackwell designs from Nvidia will almost certainly require liquid cooling. For example many air cooled Hopper racks are already up to 40W which many data centers cannot handle. Nvidia is also releasing a CPU which is claimed to be twice as energy efficient as Intel CPUs. It seems the industry is heading towards energy efficiency and liquid cooling. Supermicro is a leader in rack-space liquid cooling and as they say in their presentations “rack is the new unit of compute”.

AppLovin - 17.6%
I wrote up my thoughts on their last earnings which I was impressed by. They are now growing 48% year over year and this last quarter was over a billion in revenue. EBITDA was 453M and their AXON-2 system has something like 70-80% EBITDA pull through, or almost all profit on any revenue! As they say if a customer can spend $1 and get $2 back, that customer will try and do that spending as many times are possible.

They are in the free to play games business which I believe the market doesn’t take seriously. However, this industry of free to play games has a massive secular tailwind with many companies looking to add free to play games after seeing the success of other companies doing this to drive traffic.

When I compare this to other software companies AppLovin appears undervalued. For example Crowdstrike is a 75B company which is the top tier of SaaS companies has 845M revenue and 60M in EBITDA, this compares to AppLovin with 1058M and 453M of EBITDA. I know some would argue AppLovin isn’t SaaS and their is no guarantee their customers will return. What the company and results show is that the customers are clamoring to spend as much as they can because the ROI is big, instant, and attributable.

AppLovin has ambitions to get into other aspects of AdTech specifically CTV, and they say their AI platform can be applied to other industries fairly seamlessly.

From their results AppLovin is the only software company I have seen which has had a dramatic improvements of results because of AI. I keep seeing other software companies talking about the benefits of AI, but it doesn’t show up in their results the same way it does for AppLovin.

Nvidia - 17.1%
I wrote up some quick thoughts on the Nvidia quarter. Everything seems on track here with EPS growing 629%! I’m impressed by the promise of Blackwell being 30x faster and 25x more energy efficient than Hopper.

Jensen says they sales cycle will take 4-5 years before Hoppers start getting replaced. I expect this secular AI boom in semiconductors to go on many years and Nvidia is the clear leader.

Elf - 15.4%
I wrote up my thoughts on the earnings. The quarter was an absolute blowout and the concerns about Ulta mid quarter were clearly overblown. I was disappointed with the CFOs guidance of 20-22%. After hours I saw the price of ELF go as low as $138, and then it went up to over $190 in the next few days. I get that CFO’s manipulate the guidance game, but this CFO seems to playing the game particularly poorly. This is evidenced by the entire call being dominated by questions on guidance rather than questions on the business.

Overall, I kept my position as I see the business on track and confirmed there has been a repeated history of yearly guides that make zero sense. I see this as a strong brand that has potential to grow into a company that is the size of the larger makeup brands. The company is just ramping for international and it seems like an outstanding success so far, particularly in Italy and Netherlands.

Hims and Hers Health - 15.2%
I increased my position after this latest earnings significantly and wrote up some thoughts. I was really fortunate to increase after the report as the company announced they will be able to offer a GLP-1 injectable soon and the stock shot up 30% in one day! The share price was $12.5 at the start of May and is now $19.4

When I initially wrote up an intro for HIMS many of the critiques were that the sequential revenue ads were flat, basically they were adding 15-20M per quarter. However, this quarter was 31M of revenue added and they added a record 170k new customers to go from 1.5M → 1.7M customers. Additionally they mention Hers, the woman’s side of the business is growing incredibly fast.

Another critique in the initial write up was that growth seemed to be dropping off fast. Their previous quarters of revenue growth were 88% → 83% → 57% → 48%, but this quarter came in at 46% and they guided for future 40%+ growth.

The brand is getting more recognition and taking market share. I believe this company has an interesting loop hole for offering new products is the best way to describe it. There’s an FDA regulation 503B that allows HIMS or others to produce “compounded” drugs if there is a shortage of drugs. For example, Ozempic and Wegovy the weight loss drugs are in shortage so the FDA has given HIMS the approval to produce a GLP-1. While it’s not technically and FDA approved drug it has the explicit approval of the FDA to be sold. The best part is the underlying ingredients are sourced from the FDA and sent to pharmacies which HIMS owns in the USA. HIMS has two “affiliated pharmacies” which is a term I believe doesn’t accurately describe what is it - they completely own the pharmacies and production.

Lastly, this business seems undervalued to me. Comparing to the other consumer I own of ELF and CELH, HIMS has a much lower P/S ratio and they are becoming increasingly profitable.

Transmedics - 13.8%
I wrote up my thoughts on their earnings. It was a great report and profitability came in much higher than expected. Analysts expected them to be about break even and they earned close to 12M! I haven’t done a lot of research since the earnings but this is still a moderately high conviction stock for me.

Celsius - 1.6%
I sold off almost all of Celsius, although I’m still bullish on the company. I really didn’t understand how much leverage their distributors have over their inventory especially Pepsi, and that’s some concern to me that they may not control their destiny here.

Another somewhat concerning thing to me was they plan to quadruple their sales staff but haven’t really explained in depth why. My guess is it’s all for international, but I do wonder if this may hurt their bottom line in the near term before revenue starts to ramp up.

One of the main reasons I sold is when I compare Celsius side by side with ELF and HIMS. Celsius is a market cap of 18B, ELF 10B, and HIMS 5B. They are all roughly in the same ballpark of revenue with ELF and CELH slightly above HIMS, but I’d rather have my money in HIMS and ELF right now. I may end up adding some if the price comes down much and looks like a good opportunity.

Companies I sold,

AXON
My main thesis behind this investment was that Taser10 was going to be an absolute game changer because of it’s increased capacity, 10 rounds versus 2, and increased range. I no longer really believe this to be the case. Additionally I have very low confidence in management which has shown a history of unethical behavior in recent years. That’s in addition to having invested in this company many years ago in the 2000s and being burned by the same CEO’s profligate spendings.

I’m concerned about the CEO’s focus on drones. In September 2023 the entire Axon ethics board resigned after the CEO bypassed the board to try and go ahead creating an autonomous drone equipped with Tasers that would chase down the sounds of gunshots and tase in that area. The company recently acquired SkyHero after this, and then realized after acquiring it they wouldn’t have FAA approval to use this product.

The company is responsible for promoting a medical condition called excited delirium and the wikipedia page on this condition is heavily associated with Axon. The company paid medical doctors to reclassify Taser related deaths as a new condition to hide the fact that Tasers are lethal some of the time. The wikipedia page links to Washington Post story about “excited delirium” may be a cover for police brutality, and in may cases officers are trigger happy to use a taser.

A Reuters report emphasized the toxic workplace that Axon promotes including trying to get employees to get Axon tattoos, being tased at the workplace, and setting up living places at Axon headquarters to employees would basically live at the company. The idea of getting a company branded tattoo at a time when company loyalty to employees is at an all time low seems insane to me.

Going back to 2006 or so when I first started investing in this company as the company started losing business the two founders, both brothers increasing the spending to out of control levels including buying multiple private jets, retina scanners to enter the building, and marble flooring. They claimed they needed all these items to impress customers.

On the recent quarter they mentioned they are “cautious on EBITDA” and introduced a new metric adjusted gross margin to take out SBC. Devices were lighter than expected and Taser10 was supply blocked from producing enough. However, software and ARR came in very strong which carried the quarter.

There was a comment on selling Taser to Australia and went I looked into this T7 was previously sold to all nine Australian airports, but it doesn’t sound like the airports have decided to buy T10 yet which gives me a lot of concern.

Lastly I believe this company is looking to do M&A for the sake of it rather than adding strategically. They say they will look to do M&A more aggressively and it makes me wonder why this engineering work is not done in house. The AXON Body-4 grew 14% year over year and this product has had some issues with them occasionally catching on fire.

Overall I believe this company’s ethical lapses by the CEO will eventually catch up with them, and it may be part of the reason there seems to be little traction on T10 sales internationally when this product seems like it would the perfect fit for countries like Australia and the UK.

ARM
I started a medium size position in ARM and then sold only after two days. Wrote up my full thoughts on in it in this thread.

Companies I looked into,

Sarepeta Therapeutics (SRPT)
They made genetic medicines for rare diseases with muscular conditions. They have 63% revenue growth, positive EBITDA and net income. Ultimately the conditions they treat are rare and I have some questions if the market is big enough.

Sportradar (SRAD)
They provide sports metrics data for other companies to consume. Revenue is only growing 28%, but their US based business is growing 60%. Founded in Norway and HQ is in Switzerland. They’ve proven their product works internationally to start with which I like. I have this one on a close watchlist to see if the next quarter can get to 30%+ revenue and I could start a position potentially.

Aspen Aerogels (ASPN)
Wrote up my thoughts on their last quarter I just didn’t feel I have a good enough grasp on this product to start a position but I’m interested in this company.

Tidewater (TDW)
Provides offshore service vehicles and marine support services. Financials look great and it’s the second or third time I’ve looked into the company but just cannot get ramped up enough on the product to be comfortable.

Celestica (CLS)
Canadian competitor to Supermicro, smaller and worse margins but they have some big contracts with hyper-scalers. P/E is 20 or so and they have a lot of legacy business but their AI business is growing ~60%. Feels like a second rate Supermicro but I’m interested to see if revenue can pick up from here.

60 Likes

Our portfolios are similar, wpr!

Most of my companies have been covered more than adequately, but let me mention a bit about TSLA…

I plan to trim something (probably APP & CELH) for TSLA somewhere around 2Q results, which closely precedes the robotaxi unveiling. I believe TSLA is way under appreciated for 1) FSD progress, 2) Energy segment growth and 3) the impact of the intro of robotaxi and the other new vehicle(s) to enter production soon, along with the financial impact of the Cybertruck. That’s offset (I think) by poor results for 2Q. Why not add now? Because I expect TSLA to remain somewhat flattish until my purchase time and both APP and CELH should gain some by then. And TSLA might even tank a bit with upcoming bad news in sales. I expect Musk’s compensation to be re-approved but have doubts about their success in moving incorporation to TX.

Current status is roughly NVDA 72%, SMCI 17%, CELH 7%, APP 2%, EOSE 1%. None of that is a typo.

I’m not sure how fast and how much I’ll ramp up my TSLA position, it depends on how all these moving parts move. But I envision TSLA being a BIG allocation sometime in the next twelve months, mostly by addition.

YTD: ~+330%

Rob
He is no fool who gives what he cannot keep to gain what he cannot lose.

28 Likes

@wpr101 Nice write up. I am curious what your ytd return is? Phil Fisher, the godfather of growth investing, is indeed a classic. The entire Motley Fool philosophy is based on Phil. I just read another great investing book. It’s called 100 baggers by Chris Mayer. Great case studies of 100 baggers such as Monster, Berkshire, Southwest Airlines, etc. Author talks a lot about how the twin engines of massive upward stock movements are multiple expansion along with strong EPS growth.

8 Likes

It’s tricky for me to calculate precisely because I have a number of different accounts and sometimes do withdrawals for expenses. Additionally, there’s a couple off topic investments like IBIT - Blackrock Bitcoin ETF, and the occasional options trade.

Looking at just account values from January 1 to now, I’m up 53% year to date. A large portion of the return was driven by Supermicro which started the year at $300 and was already a large position by then, but I’ve trimmed as it went up some because it was getting to be too large a position. Transmedics has helped a decent amount too starting the year at $75, but that was more of a medium/small position to start the year with.

I just read another great investing book. It’s called 100 baggers by Chris Mayer. Great case studies of 100 baggers such as Monster, Berkshire, Southwest Airlines, etc.

Will definitely check that one out now! I had seen it on Amazon and thought to order before.


I was curious are you still invested in Aspen Aerogels and what is your conviction like on that company?

Do you know if Tesla is a customer of them? I was finding contradictory information whether they were or not. Mostly I was trying to figure out if Tesla is not using them, do they have some alternative in-house product they use to reduce the potential of battery fires.

3 Likes

@wpr101 Yes, I’m still invested in ASPN. I started building a position in late February. I build it up to around a 6% position and then it went crazy and turned into a 9.9% position without me adding a dime.

Jonah Lupton did a mini deep dive back in January on Seeking Alpha.

From the article:

“General Motors [GM] was the first pilot customer who pretty soon signed a long-term agreement with Aspen to supply thermal barriers for use in the battery system of its next-generation electric vehicles. GM has remained the largest customer ever since. This deal helped to unlock agreements with other OEMs, including Toyota (in 2021), Audi (in 2023), Scania (in 2023), Honda (in 2024), and Acura (in 2024). More deals are in the pipeline that we should hear about in 2024 and beyond.”

A recent Motley Fool article also noted that Aspen has a multiyear contract with Automotive Cells Company, a battery-cell joint venture between Stellantis N.V. , Saft (a TotalEnergies subsidiary), and Mercedes-Benz .

“We remain deeply engaged with a growing list of automotive OEMs and battery cell manufacturers and have strong conviction that we are providing a unique solution to a very challenging problem,” CEO Don Young said in a recent statement. “We remain focused on scaling the five OEM awards that we have in hand alongside maximizing our Energy Industrial business.”

I cannot speak much to the exact width of their MOAT (I’m no expert in the space) but the fact that they have a lot of patents and so many Auto/OEM’s on board, is very encouraging to me. There is no doubt the runway for EV’s and hybrids is long. I haven’t seen any concrete evidence or assertion that Tesla is a customer.

My portfolio is doing ok this year, I’m up about 45% ytd. TMDX, ASPN, SMCI, and CELH have done pretty well for me. I have trimmed CELH down from 15% to 3% over the past few months & SMCI from 12% to 3% as well.

I did subscribe to Jonah Lupton’s service in January, he’s a great investor, so it is helping me take my investing to the next level. He has great investment models for reference & regular deep dives. I also watch Dumbmoney weekly for Social Arb/trends knowledge & ideas.

10 Likes

I did subscribe to Jonah Lupton’s service in January, he’s a great investor, so it is helping me take my investing to the next level. He has great investment models for reference & regular deep dives. I also watch Dumbmoney weekly for Social Arb/trends knowledge & ideas.

Nice, I’m familiar with both of those sources. I’d been following Jonah Lupton on Twitter for some time and subscribed about a month and half ago to his growth service. Definitely getting the value there from his deep dive write-ups, I think I missed the write-up on Aspen so will check that one out.

I read about Chris Camillo in the Unknown Market Wizards book and his interview was probably the most useful I found from that whole set of interviews. He also has a book called Laughing at Wall Street that I read. I like the Dumbmoney weekly too that he hosts, but I think his two cohosts are not on the same level.

I have trimmed CELH down from 15% to 3% over the past few months & SMCI from 12% to 3% as well.

Was wondering did you trim SMCI for valuation reasons or something fundamental with the business? Anything you see that I may be missing from my analysis?

2 Likes

@wpr101 I’m not sure you are missing anything with SMCI. I just feel that because it is making a commodity-like product, a white server box, that it doesn’t have much of a MOAT and could be disrupted easily or hit supply chain snags, etc so. It is also a low margin, cyclical business with lots of price wars. I started trumming once it hit 1k or so. I just don’t feel comfortable holding a large position over the long run in this type of business. Maybe, I’m wrong, AI is a huge buildout - but I could see a lot of investors bailing as soon as growth rates start to normalize a bit.

Also, i have a position in Nvdia and I work for a leading wafer fab equipment company that grants me RSU’s so I don’t want too many eggs in one basket.

7 Likes

Related. Last segment warns that the pace of AI spending could slow, and investor expectations could be too high.

1:37:38 Are we seeing an AI Correction?

2 Likes

I beat you by a hour and change here:

10 Likes

I’m a huge fan of the Allin Pod and have caught almost every episode since the first one. However, I think this segment towards the end was shallow and poorly researched by the Besties.

First, Chamath’s position on anything is hard to take seriously because he only talks his book or lack there of. If he got into something early and profited, he will talk about how it was clear as day what the correct bet was and how everybody missed it. If he missed some big trend like hardware AI acceleration then he denigrates it. I’ve never seen him once talk about SPACs on the pod or how he was on CNBC promoting them all the time, since those did not do well. Even the other Besties have called him out on it multiple times before, saying something like “You are just on tilt because you didn’t invest in it”, and he’s admitted that before.

It’s telling that Chamath says AI is only voice chatbots. He refuses to acknowledge any productivity gains that Jason pointed out, and says everyone will stop spending. Ironically it’s Meta his former employer who has been one of the large spenders on AI hardware. They’ve gotten a clear ROI from it as Mark Zuckerberg has explained many times on a new items ranging from way more effective ads, and the ability to reduce headcount for content moderation as the AI can do it.

Friedberg seems to base his whole position that AI is slowing down because Dell went down 20%. He didn’t cite any metrics for Dell or anything he is tracking about the company except noting it was down, and therefore bad. Jason pointed out Dell’s had a huge run-up going into this report, and over the last year.

Having looked into the Dell report myself I thought it was mostly positive about the huge growth in AI, but they said margins will decline by 150 bps because of a mix of more AI servers and the market freaked out about that. I’m not sure why anybody would expect one of the main players from the CPU revolution to be the same one this cycle. I see Dell playing catch up to Supermicro and I didn’t see Dell mention liquid cooling once, I believe all their systems are air cooled which is going to hurt their results very soon.

Jason seemed to have the most balanced and knowledgable approach. He says there’s basically 30-40% gains in worker productivity that he has seen hands on with the startups he advises. Also says it’s probably a blip.

23 Likes

@wpr101. All good points. I do have a position in Meta as well. I think we are in the early innings of the AI wave but I am always on the lookout for possible speedbumps. Perhaps I will bump my SMCI position back up a bit. Again, I don’t see any issues with SMCI performance - but a low margin hardware commodity business in a cyclical industry makes me nervous. I won’t lose sleep to make $$ ala the famous Warren Buffet quote. Dell stock price will likely recover quickly, the dip was nonsense and AI server growth is promising.

What about Elf? I had a 16% position but started to trim after it hit $200+ a few months ago. I trimmed it to down to 3% and then sold it all after earnings. Why? It’s too expensive. I love the company but even if it does say, 50% topline this year, I don’t see much upside. And the multiples will compress as it slows. Great company, expensive stock. This is my big shift, in the past I would have kept Elf, it’s firing on all cylinders so let it ride, right? But, my investment model, doesn’t show a lot of upside over the next couple years at today’s prices.

I’m curious to hear your thoughts on Elf.

11 Likes

Valuation wise it seems fairly valued to me. One thing I’m still trying to wrap my head around is how Estee Lauder (EL) has a 70 P/E ratio, and L’Oreal has a P/E of 40. They both are not growing but for some reason the market supports high price multiples for this type of company.

I think the growth story for ELF will continue for awhile and part of that will be international expansion. Something I’m encouraged a lot by is the retailers they have gone into in Italy and Netherlands already have them as the number one brand. That’s surprising to me somewhat they can basically launch as number one, and there must be tremendous buzz around their brand in Europe to make that the case. Additionally, the European consumer is more price sensitive than the American one, and products like cosmetics are sometimes already priced higher in Europe than they are in America to begin with.

I like that ELF used to be a much smaller grower for many years and then ramped up up into growth rates of 70%+. Most companies I follow it’s the opposite of explosive growth which tapers off.

Ultimately I believe ELF has the potential to reach the same scale as a Estee Lauder or L’Oreal which would be a multi-bagger from the current market cap of ~10B. I’ll probably stay around as long as the story sounds in tact and the growth rate stays high. Will be following the next quarter pretty closely though to confirm their full year guide doesn’t carry any weight.

19 Likes